Duncan v Berrcerra

CrabcakesAndFootball · Mar 29, 2019

Ben Shapiro is retweeting screen grabs from this monster 86 page opinion on twitter. This one is really great. Sorry if this is upside down:

GTOGUNNER · Mar 29, 2019

It is upside down for what we would have expected from California. ..

Kharn · Mar 29, 2019

It's time to poop or get off the toilet, and that Sears catalog isn't going to read itself. 9th, en banc, 1 First, here we come.

motorcoachdoug · Mar 30, 2019

Made for interesting reading!!! We need to send a copy to Her Frosh and all his minions starting with the Head Minion at MSP!

danb · Mar 30, 2019

Do we? I have mixed feelings. Maybe we should keep them in the dark, in denial, so when their vajajays get smacked hard its a total surprise.

ngman · Mar 30, 2019

I’ve only read through a third of it so far, but I was smiling with every page. The nuances and implications are beyond me and I need to finish reading it but, I didn’t like all the references to “inside” the home. It felt like a line was being drawn.

Dogabutila · Mar 30, 2019

What kind of world is it when California can have standard mags, and DC can have carry permits.. and MD is falling far behind?

IronEye · Mar 30, 2019

That opinion was a good read and very understandable. I recommend it.

Muleskinner · Mar 30, 2019

Dogabutila said:
What kind of world is it when California can have standard mags, and DC can have carry permits.. and MD is falling far behind?

A world where we are not equal under the law

Invicta · Mar 30, 2019

danb said:
Do we? I have mixed feelings. Maybe we should keep them in the dark, in denial, so when their vajajays get smacked hard its a total surprise.

I doubt any of them are in the dark about this. They are probably fuming and trying to figure out the best way to minimize the impact of this. Frosh is probably one of the ones strategizing with CA as to whether or not they should fight it and risk it impacting the rest of the country.

teratos · Mar 30, 2019

Invicta said:
I doubt any of them are in the dark about this. They are probably fuming and trying to figure out the best way to minimize the impact of this. Frosh is probably one of the ones strategizing with CA as to whether or not they should fight it and risk it impacting the rest of the country.

I don’t know how aware they are of things. Yes, there are some very smart/cunning legislators. Many are just downright stupid.

Allen65 · Mar 30, 2019

Invicta said:
I doubt any of them are in the dark about this. They are probably fuming and trying to figure out the best way to minimize the impact of this. Frosh is probably one of the ones strategizing with CA as to whether or not they should fight it and risk it impacting the rest of the country.

Frosh doesn't have to care, for now. We're in 4th CA, not 9th, and 4th has already spoken about MD's AWB and mag cap limits in Kolbe. The 9th's decision creates a clear circuit split, but until someone manages to get SCOTUS to resolve the split, Frosh can sit around drinking cocoa and being happy.

rockstarr · Apr 1, 2019

Allen65 said:
Frosh doesn't have to care, for now. We're in 4th CA, not 9th, and 4th has already spoken about MD's AWB and mag cap limits in Kolbe. The 9th's decision creates a clear circuit split, but until someone manages to get SCOTUS to resolve the split, Frosh can sit around drinking cocoa and being happy.

maybe this will be the decision that gets the supreme court US, to grant cert and take the case.

CrabcakesAndFootball · Apr 1, 2019

The final judgment in Duncan that came out last week was from a district court. I anticipate that California will likely appeal to the Ninth Circus b/c it is still stacked with activists. It will take an opinion of a Ninth Circus panel affirming the district court, that doesn't get reversed en banc, to really crystallize a circuit split between the Ninth and the Third and make the matter ripe for SCOTUS review.

The New York transport law case (I forget the name) could throw that whole timeline on its head if these courts have been applying improper scrutiny to these laws, which is what the district court judge in Duncan argues.

Mike OTDP · Apr 1, 2019

teratos said:
Many are just downright stupid.

That's putting it mildly. If the general public really understood just how ignorant their legislators really were, I suspect there would be a panic.

rbird7282 · Apr 1, 2019

Mike OTDP said:
That's putting it mildly. If the general public really understood just how ignorant their legislators really were, I suspect there would be a panic.

Just goes to show you how ignorant many voters are. They do zero research on issues or candidates and vote for them based on a television ad.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

BeoBill · Apr 1, 2019

danb said:
Do we? I have mixed feelings. Maybe we should keep them in the dark, in denial, so when their vajajays get smacked hard its a total surprise.

I'm sure he has a paid minion here in constant contact with the minions in CA about this. And Shannon. And Blomberg's legal quislings.

BeoBill · Apr 1, 2019

Dogabutila said:
What kind of world is it when California can have standard mags, and DC can have carry permits.. and MD is falling far behind?

The MGA is DESPERATELY CLUTCHING NJ and NYC at this point.

BeoBill · Apr 1, 2019

Mike OTDP said:
That's putting it mildly. If the general public really understood just how ignorant their legislators really were, I suspect there would be a panic.

I doubt that, as long as they have their beer, circuses and SNAP cards.

wolfwood · Jul 16, 2019

opening brief filed

https://www.scribd.com/document/417683498/Duncan-Ninth-Circuit-Opening-Brief-by-State-of-California

Duncan v Berrcerra

The #1 community for Gun Owners of the Northeast

Member Benefits:

Active Member

Attachments

IANAL, PATRIOT PICKET!!

Ultimate Member

Ultimate Member

dont be a dumbass

Active Member

Ultimate Member

Active Member

Ultimate Member

Active Member

My hair is amazing

Ultimate Member

Major Deplorable

Active Member

Ultimate Member

Ultimate Member

Crank in the Third Row

Crank in the Third Row

Crank in the Third Row

Ultimate Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Log in

Forum statistics