LOL. I truly enjoy both weapons. I have a buddy who was heavy into C&R back when I just got out of college. I should have heeded his advice back then and spent the $30 for the license, but dragged my feet for another decade. That was back when Mosins were $50 a pop and 98k and Enfield rifles were still cheap. It was post Saving Private Ryan and Band of Brothers had just finished airing the original run-through so M1's and carbines were starting to jump up in price a bit. He and I would go shooting together and he would bring out the Garand and carbine every once in a while so long as I grabbed ammo. The pawn shop the next county over sold bandoleers of surplus .30-06 in the clips with the cardboard sleeves still stuffed in the bandoleers they were packed in. The carbine is definitely much easier to put a lot of rounds down-range with , but the Garand has never been a shoulder-puncher in my experience. The one thing the Garand has above all though is the "ping" at the end. Nothing else comes close, not even Manlicher or Berthier en-blocs dropping out the bottom of their magazines on the last round stripped.
That ping is the sound of freedom. It’s like a bald eagle screaming in your face.
That ping might as well be a Garand screaming “F yeah! Murica and freedom!”