Sussex Decent Pizza Places

[lazybones]

They were talking about pizza.

Defibios Market in Bethan Beach. Most of the time. They are often short-staffed so the pickings can be slim.

 

[lazybones]

Milton Dough Bar. Nice view of a park and inlet if you eat outside.

 

[-Z/28-]

Grotto Pizza

Eww. I do not understand Delawarians obsession with Grotto. Most bland, bleh pizza at the beach.

 

[bigjohn]

Yeah. Realized that after I hit the button

 

[del_patriot]

I would have to recommend Grottos. Other than that I am hardly over by the beaches so I can't be of much help. I stick to western Sussex.

 

[adit]

Eww. I do not understand Delawarians obsession with Grotto. Most bland, bleh pizza at the beach.

Delawareans don't eat it, the Tourists do.

 

[Huckleberry]

Delawareans don't eat it, the Tourists do.

Delawareans?

I thought they voted for Delawarers because Delawareans sounded too soft

 

[del_patriot]

Eww. I do not understand Delawarians obsession with Grotto. Most bland, bleh pizza at the beach.

I was born and raised here and love it. A lot of people hate on it and like to hate on it, but it is our thing...

 

[Terps]

DeFebos Market (Bethany) has a wood style pizza oven. I like to grab a slice there or Pomodoro.

THIS!!! Also try “Pie” in Bethany. Pomodoro is great, but I’m not sure they are open year round. Best NY style Pizza around. Pie and Difibo’s are more “artist” small pizzas

 

[RFBfromDE]

I was born and raised here and love it. A lot of people hate on it and like to hate on it, but it is our thing...

Yes, but back in the day the dough was tossed and the crispy crust had blisters.

Now the dough is machine pressed and I don’t think the ovens are hot enough.

 

[308Scout]

Yes, but back in the day the dough was tossed and the crispy crust had blisters.

Now the dough is machine pressed and I don’t think the ovens are hot enough.

Last time I had Grotto a couple of years ago, it was essentially just glorified "food court pizza". I remember it being better long ago, and this is probably why.

 

[Darkemp]

Laurel Pizzeria- locations in Laurel and Seaford. Great pizza.

Laurel Pizzeria

A little bit of Italy in your own backyard

laurelpizzeria.com

 

[Darkemp]

Lat time I had Grotto a couple of years ago, it was essentially just glorified "food court pizza". I remember it being better long ago, and this is probably why.

It was good at UD on Main St in Newark, but the atmosphere was better than the food as I remember.

 

[Overboost44]

I have two brothers that live in Lewes and Mr. P's is the go to with Touch of Italy as an alternative. If the Ava's Pizzeria down in Rehoboth is as good as the one in St. Michael's you should try that.

ETA: Full Belly Pizza is pretty good and I didn't see it mentioned here.

 

[wpage]

Would not classify Grotto Pizza as decent. It is convenient (by Home Depo) and inexpensive...

However, if your hungry it will fill the void. And, the beer is cold.

 

[HailVon]

The new Nicola's up by Home Depot just opened. Haven't been there yet (old locations were good).

Mama Maria's in Dewey and Milford is good.
Mama Celeste in Dewey is good as well, but they are only open next Friday/Saturday night, and are closing (retiring) for good.

Bella Capri in Georgetown, next to Walmart, is another option.

Nicola’s has to be one of the best pizza places out there!

 

[RFBfromDE]

Would not classify Grotto Pizza as decent. It is convenient (by Home Depo) and inexpensive...

However, if your hungry it will fill the void. And, the beer is cold.

In season, I like to hit up the location on the Rehoboth boardwalk for $5 Big Beers in a frosty mug.

 

[del_patriot]

Nicola’s has to be one of the best pizza places out there!

I would disagree honestly. Not a huge fan of theirs. It used to be fun going town to the original location for half priced Nicabolis in the winter, but it was more of an experience thing than for the quality of food. Over in western Sussex Pizza King and Cafe Tamburelli's are pretty good options.

 

[HailVon]

I would disagree honestly. Not a huge fan of theirs. It used to be fun going town to the original location for half priced Nicabolis in the winter, but it was more of an experience thing than for the quality of food. Over in western Sussex Pizza King and Cafe Tamburelli's are pretty good options.

I’ll probably need to try them next summer when visiting my family!