NYC CCW case is at SCOTUS!

[teratos]

I don't think that is what happened.

Dammit, you’re right. I thought the pro-gun guy was saying SCOTUS sided with common sense…nope. I read too fast.

Temporary set-back.

 

[Zaicran]

Justice Thomas denied NY’s motion to be tyrants.

Huh?

 

[DaemonAssassin]

Did you just compare gun ownership (to keep) and carrying (to bear) which is a right protected by the 2nd amendment to driving a car/insurance on a public road? (A privilege, not a right).

What's next? You think someone should have to get a license and training (ie permission from the government) to pray? Vote?

You do know that post was almost 3 years ago and posted before the SCOTUS decision, right?

 

[Worsley]

Justice Thomas denied NY’s motion to be tyrants.

Got it - at stake was where and when New Yorkers could exercise their 2A rights?

 

[Zaicran]

You do know that post was almost 3 years ago and posted before the SCOTUS decision, right?

Still needed to be said. Sick of hearing people comparing 2A to a drivers license...

 

[DaemonAssassin]

Still needed to be said. Sick of hearing people comparing 2A to a drivers license...

Carry permits should be treated like a driver's license in regards to national reciprocity.

 

[Zaicran]

Carry permits should be treated like a driver's license in regards to national reciprocity.

2A *is* the permit. Requiring permits is well, blatantly unconstitutional. But no worry..I've long ago gave up convincing the sheeple not to give up their rights. You do you, it's all good.

 

[DaemonAssassin]

2A *is* the permit. Requiring permits is well, blatantly unconstitutional. But no worry..I've long ago gave up convincing the sheeple not to give up their rights. You do you, it's all good.

And yet you can't see the things I left unsaid due to being blinded by the "MAH RIGHT" mentality.

You have to start somewhere, and considering how many states have gone ConCarry, you may want to dial back the fire, buddy. The war rages on, so it's better to not blow your wad so early.

 

[RennBaer]

Got it - at stake was where and when New Yorkers could exercise their 2A rights?

This particular request for relief from the plaintiffs was regarding NY's new ammo background check and NY taking over the entire NICS background check process (they are now the middleman for NICS checks and the FFLs aren't allowed to contact NICS directly) that recently went into effect. People were hoping that SCOTUS might address the entirety of NY's anti-2A bill and not just the background check stuff.

 

[teratos]

Got it - at stake was where and when New Yorkers could exercise their 2A rights?

Go back, I just read it wrong. Temporary set back.

 

[Zaicran]

And yet you can't see the things I left unsaid due to being blinded by the "MAH RIGHT" mentality.

You have to start somewhere, and considering how many states have gone ConCarry, you may want to dial back the fire, buddy. The war rages on, so it's better to not blow your wad so early.

OK //rolls eyes

 

[DaemonAssassin]

OK //rolls eyes

You want to put it that way? Let's go to the capital building with you carrying. You have no permit but the 2A. Let's see how that goes for you. I'll even film it all for your defense.

 

[delaware_export]

Update. I think I have the correct bruen…

NY still has not paid the court costs of losing

 

[Crazytrain]

Update. I think I have the correct bruen…

NY still has not paid the court costs of losing

They should go after the State House as compensation. I mean, if it's good enough for Latitia...

 

[Bob A]

Take it out in acreage in Central Park.

Build a shooting range.

 

[Allen65]

Take it out in acreage in Central Park.

Build a shooting range.

Wouldn't you rather watch as Gov. Hochul or AG James is arrested for Contempt of Court? I know I would.

 

[308Scout]

Take it out in acreage in Central Park.

Build a shooting range.

Love the sentiment, but given NYC property prices, that judgment would purchase maybe ~400 sq ft and likely a lot less in Manhattan.

 

[delaware_export]

Hmmm per FPC

Finally got paid base amount but not interest…

a year and a half? Whatcha think will happen if it takes tRump to pay his 500m$?

 

[Afrikeber]

Love the sentiment, but given NYC property prices, that judgment would purchase maybe ~400 sq ft and likely a lot less in Manhattan.

Upstate rural New York properties are a bargain right now.

 

[delaware_export]

as noted on the FPC/hawaii twit feeds today, Mr George young has passed. He fought the state of Hawaii for about 10 years to get his permit. His case was one of those effected by bruen and shall issue. It doesn’t epdlicitly say if he received his permit.

and THEY did their best to drag his case out so he woild pass before they had to issue.

be at peace mr young